Quality Evaluation for Indoor Mobile Data Customers in Addis Ababa Business Area Using Data from Network Management System, Walk Test, Crowdsourcing and Subjective Survey

Introduction and penetration of high-speed and innovative mobile data services including social media and video services have been increasing significantly across the globe. This growth is driven by deployment and availability of capable and affordable mobile networks and smartphones. These trends have also been observed in Ethiopia as the country’s sole incumbent operator ethio telecom has expanded coverage and capacity of its mobile data network, especially for universal mobile telecommunications system (UMTS) network. The successful provision of these innovative services requires mobile operators to have continuous monitoring of the quality of their networks and customer satisfaction. To that end, this monitoring allows the operator to make timely network optimization, marketing and other relevant decisions that enhance service quality. Traditionally measurement and analysis of network quality of service (QoS) is performed using data from network management system (NMS) and drive/walk test (DT/WT). In recent times, the usage QoS data from crowdsourcing (CS) is also emerging as useful monitoring tool. However, all these methods do not fully capture users’ quality of experience (QoE), which is a function of not only network QoS but also other factors including subjective users’ technical literacy and opinion. As a result, operators have recently provided attention not only for QoS but also QoE. Yet, most quality related analyses are performed using data from only subjective survey, NMS, DT/WT, or CS. It is not straightforward to find quality investigation based on data from all the methods. More importantly, such quality investigation has not been made in the context of Ethiopia’s mobile market. In this paper, we perform QoS and QoE evaluation for UMTS mobile data service based on quality data from all NMS, WT, CS and subjective survey for a business area in Addis Ababa. The evaluation is made using downlink user throughput and mean opinion score (MOS) metrics. The obtained 50^th percentile throughput results from NMS, WT and CS are good enough for web browsing and offline video streaming but not for high definition (HD) video calls and live HD video streaming. Furthermore, CS provides optimistic results compared to NMS and WT and its 90^th percentile throughput is very good even for live HD video streaming. Moreover, the obtained MOS results from subjective survey almost fit to the QoS results, thus indicating that the network QoS is a significant contributor to users’ perceived QoE.