TY - JOUR
T1 - Capacity Design of a Kraft Lignin Biorefinery for Production of Biophenol via a Proprietary Low-Temperature/Low-Pressure Lignin Depolymerization Process
AU - Dessbesell, Luana
AU - Yuan, Zhongshun
AU - Leitch, Mathew
AU - Paleologou, Michael
AU - Pulkki, Reino
AU - Xu, Chunbao Charles
N1 - Funding Information:
The financial support for this work was mainly from NSERC and the Ontario government via an NSERC Discovery Grant, the NSERC/FPInnovations Industrial Research Chair program, an ORF-RE grant in Forest Biorefinery, and NSERC Biomaterials and Chemicals Strategic Research Network (Lignoworks). The authors also acknowledge Palisade Corporation for making available free of cost the full version of the @Risk tool for the Monte Carlo simulations and graphical presentation. Additionally, the authors acknowledge Map Business Online − SpatialTEQ, Inc. for allowing the use of the map in Figure 1, developed by the authors in the trial version of Map Business Online. One of the authors (L.D.) also gratefully acknowledges a Brazil Science Without Borders/ CNPq Graduate Scholarship.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2018 American Chemical Society.
PY - 2018/7/2
Y1 - 2018/7/2
N2 - In Canada, there is a kraft lignin (KL) surplus of ∼1.06 millions (M) t·year-1 (after ensuring pulp mills' recovery boiler demand). This KL supply can create a US$1.5 billion lignin-based bioproducts industry. Lower molecular weight and higher reactivity depolymerized kraft lignin is a promising bioreplacement for petroleum-based chemicals such as phenols and polyols for the synthesis of biophenol formaldehyde or biopolyurethane resins. This work provides an economic analysis for biophenol production of a proprietary KL depolymerization process for eight scenarios with a KL treatment capacity ranging from 10,000 t·year-1 of KL to 120,000 t·year-1 and two recovery percentages (85% and 90%). The eight scenarios were examined on capital investment, manufacturing cost, net present value (NPV), and discounted payback period (PBP). A risk assessment through Monte Carlo analysis is presented to address uncertainties in capital investment, main raw materials cost, and biophenol selling price. From the analysis, the total variable manufacturing costs varies from ∼1081 up to 1101 US$·t-1, and the total fixed manufacturing costs from ∼63 to 154 US$·t-1. All scenarios are feasible; however, in small KL capacities, such as 10,000 t·year-1, the investment is less attractive yielding a PBP longer than 5 years. Although, KL capacities above 40,000 t·year-1 lead to ∼3-year PBPs and high NPVs (above US$35M). The risk analysis demonstrated that lignin-based phenol production is susceptible to biophenol price and KL cost variations.
AB - In Canada, there is a kraft lignin (KL) surplus of ∼1.06 millions (M) t·year-1 (after ensuring pulp mills' recovery boiler demand). This KL supply can create a US$1.5 billion lignin-based bioproducts industry. Lower molecular weight and higher reactivity depolymerized kraft lignin is a promising bioreplacement for petroleum-based chemicals such as phenols and polyols for the synthesis of biophenol formaldehyde or biopolyurethane resins. This work provides an economic analysis for biophenol production of a proprietary KL depolymerization process for eight scenarios with a KL treatment capacity ranging from 10,000 t·year-1 of KL to 120,000 t·year-1 and two recovery percentages (85% and 90%). The eight scenarios were examined on capital investment, manufacturing cost, net present value (NPV), and discounted payback period (PBP). A risk assessment through Monte Carlo analysis is presented to address uncertainties in capital investment, main raw materials cost, and biophenol selling price. From the analysis, the total variable manufacturing costs varies from ∼1081 up to 1101 US$·t-1, and the total fixed manufacturing costs from ∼63 to 154 US$·t-1. All scenarios are feasible; however, in small KL capacities, such as 10,000 t·year-1, the investment is less attractive yielding a PBP longer than 5 years. Although, KL capacities above 40,000 t·year-1 lead to ∼3-year PBPs and high NPVs (above US$35M). The risk analysis demonstrated that lignin-based phenol production is susceptible to biophenol price and KL cost variations.
KW - Biophenol
KW - Biorefinery
KW - Depolymerized kraft lignin
KW - Economic analysis
KW - Kraft lignin
KW - Monte Carlo simulation
KW - Plant capacity
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85048227039&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1021/acssuschemeng.8b01582
DO - 10.1021/acssuschemeng.8b01582
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85048227039
SN - 2168-0485
VL - 6
SP - 9293
EP - 9303
JO - ACS Sustainable Chemistry and Engineering
JF - ACS Sustainable Chemistry and Engineering
IS - 7
ER -